Paulus

Acquired a gorgeous 1901 HC from Coinery this week, very happy - Stuart, this is confirmation that I have received your coin and am pleased!

Another attempt to show what I meant by the coin having some lustre! I will move on and concentrate on my main focus! Thanks for all the input!

Harder to copy?

I like it too, although the eye is drawn to the thistle more than anything else ... just saying!

I should stick to what I know I think, until I have researched other areas!

Frank opinions is what I want and expect! It was only a few quid, and doubtless cleaned, but does look attractive in hand ... just wondered what people thought ... knew I hadn't got any kind of bargain or anything! Thanks Rob, yes it's very bright, I'll probably keep it for a while though, I'm sure I wouldn't entertain it if this was my collection focus area!

There is a real and present danger to our hobby, for sure. If TPGs were a guarantee of authenticity that would be great, but they are not. I am inclined to carry out a few market tests, with experienced TPGs, auction houses and dealers. This is very undermining.

In answer to The question i'd say because it's relatively cheap and an Icon of Victoria coinage. Perhaps The buyer is another Scott and does'nt have The 4 figures required to ever scratch a large itch. It is ugly though It must be a different mindset to mine, it might fill the gap but I would never want to look at it again! Each to his or her own!! Every keeper I have must be pleasing, and that includes some coins with obvious problems!

I would rather have a replica than that, you wouldn't want to look at it on a regular basis would you? Just don't get it sometimes! It ticks zero boxes for me, but I kinda guess it could for a completionist who insisted on genuine coins ... I realise the mindset of a type collector like myself is going to be very different to that of a completionist ... mind you I will need a Gothic crown for my type collection!!!

Why would ANYONE want this piece of poo at any cost more than scrap value? Some things baffle me! link

Yes, keep voicing your honest opinions Dave, it's one of the things I like about this Forum!

What did your message say Dave?

Your unrecorded 3d ... I like it but must be strict and use my budget for milled for now ... are you starting to wonder whether BIN would have been better than auction? No idea how to grade it really, except 'high'

To be fair, Dave, he's only saying the portrait is GEF. Shame it isn't the big crown though!Could do with higher resolution images, really. A lesser mark, but not excessively so, I'd have thought...not that I know anything of value about J1! What you want Dave is this...a genuine unrecorded obverse on this 1564 3d of Elizabeth! I spoke to Chris Comber and he concurs with my thoughts that this obverse was an unused (we think) die from 1561/62. The rusty die, unclogged bust, and Rose 5 supports this theory. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Rare-Unrecorded-Obverse-Elizabeth-I-1564-3d-Threepence-Bust-3F-Reverse-BCW-BA-h-/231504730087?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_3&hash=item35e6c1d7e7 Also a very rare Bust 3F Cross-Crosslet Halfgroat scheduled for the weekend too! We Or certainly i don't buy On portrait alone. The attached Coin was graded as XF. And i don't see The ebay One being half a grade better I agree Dave, but XF sounds like an American grade for EF (is that right?) so might only be GVF in the UK? So difficult to grade hammered I think, I rely on eye appeal so much more. I prefer it to the CC coin you first posted either way, it has a nice 'balance'

If there is one

PWA's Penny:

Re-post - surely these boxes don't even go for a tenth of that (I haven't checked!)?

Optimistic?

Whatever it actually is it scores 0/10 for eye appeal to me, I wouldn't give it house room!

Happy Birthday!

Goom, I can sell you a complete set for £37 + p&p, no-quibble returns accepted (no completer medal I'm afraid!)

Here's one that sold for over £100 this evening, and doesn't even exist as a genuine date for the coin (except in proof, which this isn't): link

Ummm ... that certainly highlights some differences in what you and I collect ...

Peter that is incredibly kind and thoughtful of you, I will look out for the postie with eager anticipation as I know not what the package may contain!! You are a true gent who I would dearly like to meet one day! - I will bring the Cubans and malt

Well I would class 'different numismatic designs from Celtic through to the present' as an area of focus ... I must admit I enjoy your posts of pics from your collection as they are often appealing examples of rarer designs / types, accompanied by a fascinating 'back story', relating to provenance or history