1905 Halfcrown

[azda 979]

Just spotted this, my wee heart. Grade was AU, anyone else with an opinion on grade. It will be for sale, by me

[Mat 2]

Just spotted this, my wee heart. Grade was AU, anyone else with an opinion on grade. It will be for sale, by me

I would give it an EF.

Very hard to capture the hair properly with Eddy.

[azda 979]

Well even at EF am a nervous bunny. I told the Frau that if it did'nt make its money back Ar least, i'd sell My collection and pack in collecting

[declanwmagee 122]

Hmmm. Anyone want to comment on the broken R in EDWARDVS?

I'm not qualified, but...

[azda 979]

Made just an OBV pic and blew up it a little after Declans comment about the R

[declanwmagee 122]

Just re-read a thread here where the broken R in 1905 halfcrowns was discussed, and I think the big boys concluded that a broken R did not necessarily mean the coin was iffy, just that a few known iffy examples had the same flaw.

Just as likely to be a Royal Mint flaw as a 1970s Turkish flaw!

Phew.

Edited March 1, 2011 by declanwmagee

[azda 979]

Just re-read a thread here where the broken R in 1905 halfcrowns was discussed, and I think the big boys concluded that a broken R did not necessarily mean the coin was iffy, just that a few known iffy examples had the same flaw.

Just as likely to be a Royal Mint flaw as a 1970s Turkish flaw!

Phew.

Lol, thanks for that Declan, my arse isn't squeaking yet, as it was from a dealer and have 2 weeks to keep it or send it back. Anyhoo, here's the REV

[declanwmagee 122]

bloody lovely.

I'm sure that'll be a gap in my collection for some years to come yet...

[azda 979]

debating ebay lol although i've tool some hits there recently

[Mat 2]

Two weeks, hmmmm I guess ebay may be the quick option here as long as it does not tiff the dealer off if he sees it and your going return it....

[azda 979]

If youPay your money Mat it shouldn't peeees anyone off, dealers do it all the time, buy for someone else

Let's put it this way, it was a 4 figured price tag and I'm not the most educated on fake 1905s, then Declan came up with the Borken R scenario.

I believe its kosha so am happy at that, the 2 week return is only for safety for me. Will wait for the wiser heads amoungst us.

Edited March 1, 2011 by azda

[Gary D 76]

If youPay your money Mat it shouldn't peeees anyone off, dealers do it all the time, buy for someone else

Let's put it this way, it was a 4 figured price tag and I'm not the most educated on fake 1905s, then Declan came up with the Borken R scenario.

I believe its kosha so am happy at that, the 2 week return is only for safety for me. Will wait for the wiser heads amoungst us.

If you are going to put it on the bay dipping is a must.

And speaking of the broken R there is an other 1905 on ebay.....with the broken R.

[Gary D 76]

Just re-read a thread here where the broken R in 1905 halfcrowns was discussed, and I think the big boys concluded that a broken R did not necessarily mean the coin was iffy, just that a few known iffy examples had the same flaw.

Just as likely to be a Royal Mint flaw as a 1970s Turkish flaw!

Phew.

Lol, thanks for that Declan, my arse isn't squeaking yet, as it was from a dealer and have 2 weeks to keep it or send it back. Anyhoo, here's the REV

And the dealer is not aware of it's full potential

[Mat 2]

If youPay your money Mat it shouldn't peeees anyone off, dealers do it all the time, buy for someone else

Let's put it this way, it was a 4 figured price tag and I'm not the most educated on fake 1905s, then Declan came up with the Borken R scenario.

I believe its kosha so am happy at that, the 2 week return is only for safety for me. Will wait for the wiser heads amoungst us.

Not necessarily, largely depends on the dealer and the contract law in their country. I bought a very rare gold one Lira, the dealer offered a no quibble 28 day return, I listed it for sale before it arrived but when it arrived I noticed an edge ding which was not shown in a catalogue. The seller refused the return because I had listed it for sale and the Italian solicitor that I used to start proceedings against him found that he was entitled to as in Italian law by offering an item for sale constituted as me accepting the good which disqualified the no quibble return part of the contract. Luckily I managed to break even on it.

[Accumulator 52]

Hi Azda, Can you PM me the price you're looking for, I might be interested?

[SionGilbey 1]

Hi Azda, Can you PM me the price you're looking for, I might be interested?

If you have 4 grand lying around!

[Gary D 76]

Hi Azda, Can you PM me the price you're looking for, I might be interested?

If you have 4 grand lying around!

What is the colour like in hand, the fakes tend to be very grey.

Here is the pointer, if only it made any sense.

[azda 979]

I don't know yet Gary, was just found today

[£400 for a Penny ? 0]

Well even at EF am a nervous bunny. I told the Frau that if it did'nt make its money back Ar least, i'd sell My collection and pack in collecting

I'm not a wise head, far from it, but you're proposing to 'bed and breakfast' a coin you haven't even seen in hand yet during a dealers return window and you haven't fully decided which medium you are going to use to sell, let alone a buyer ? Then there are known copies in play and you're making promises to your family like that ?

You've always been fast mate, but one can be toooo fast.

Slow down a bit, spend the next 3 months buying books, take up pipe smoking, and breathe....

x

[azda 979]

As i Said 400, if its iffy it fies back, i get my cash back and all is well in the world again, how many opportunities do you get to grab a coin like that?

It looks good and from a dealer, if it turns out iffy then we can always have good pixs as a reference for future, i've always been impulsive and wasn't going to let such a good looking coin Pass by.

I'll save the pipe smoking until i reach 21 (again)

[Peckris 579]

We're a long way off from your original question, but I'd give it a very nice GVF rather than EF.

[1949threepence 3,367]

We're a long way off from your original question, but I'd give it a very nice GVF rather than EF.

My first thought was divided between GVF and NEF.

Are you buying from a reputable dealer, Dave, and may we enquire how much you are paying/have paid for it. Personally, I'd say it was genuine. Looks like real time wear.

[azda 979]

Coin was Grades AU, i'm thinking probably American AU rather than the english version, so EF. Dealer is reputable and in Europe, quite Lear the Channel actualy that should give you a good ibdicator which country.

As for price, well for now, 4 figures and personally it does look good to me also, an honest coin As they say and by the Looks of it, it has a nice Gun metal grey to it. In Hand pictures will Be uploaded when the bugger arrives.

Peck, do you have friends who work Ar CGS? Lol

[Red Riley 2]

Coin was Grades AU, i'm thinking probably American AU rather than the english version, so EF. Dealer is reputable and in Europe, quite Lear the Channel actualy that should give you a good ibdicator which country.

As for price, well for now, 4 figures and personally it does look good to me also, an honest coin As they say and by the Looks of it, it has a nice Gun metal grey to it. In Hand pictures will Be uploaded when the bugger arrives.

Peck, do you have friends who work Ar CGS? Lol

Dave, the first thing you must do is weigh it (should be c. 14.14g give or take say, 0.1g). If it comes up short send it straight back.

[argentumandcoins 70]

The odd edge knock and some bag marking detracts a little but there is very little sign of wear.

The first points to show on the reverse are the corners of the shield and they show only the feintest trace, the garter legend is very strong. GVF is a safe assessment for buying but I would think it'll be a little bit better in the hand. Certainly not A UNC though! Never trust a dealer Dave