a fake?

[Debbie 58]

Evening all. I have a 1926 shilling (modified I think ) which is ever so slightly bigger than my other shillings which has been puzzling me. I know its slightly bigger as it doesn’t fit into any of the “shilling spaces†in my 1902 – 1936 Whitman folder ( I know this may not be the best way of storing my coins!) All the rest seem to fit perfectly snugly. Do you think it could be a fake?

[Rob 3,152]

Evening all. I have a 1926 shilling (modified I think ) which is ever so slightly bigger than my other shillings which has been puzzling me. I know its slightly bigger as it doesn’t fit into any of the “shilling spaces†in my 1902 – 1936 Whitman folder ( I know this may not be the best way of storing my coins!) All the rest seem to fit perfectly snugly. Do you think it could be a fake?

There aren't any obviously wrong indicators. How much bigger is it? Could it be struck on a flan designed for something else? If so, is it silver?

[Debbie 58]

Its only very slightly larger, almost as if the rim bows outward a little and grooves along the edge stick out too much.I'm not sure how I would test if is silver? It weighs 6g, but my scales are not super acurate.

[Nick 329]

Evening all. I have a 1926 shilling (modified I think) which is ever so slightly bigger than my other shillings which has been puzzling me. I know its slightly bigger as it doesn’t fit into any of the “shilling spaces†in my 1902 – 1936 Whitman folder ( I know this may not be the best way of storing my coins!) All the rest seem to fit perfectly snugly. Do you think it could be a fake?

It's the slightly scarcer unmodified head shilling and looks to be in a nice high grade. It doesn't look fake to me, perhaps the collar was a little worn which might explain a slight increase in diameter.

[Debbie 58]

It's the slightly scarcer unmodified head shilling and looks to be in a nice high grade

Well that's good to know,thanks Nick. It still leaves me with an unfilled gap in my folder though (and no space for a modified version)!

[Peckris 579]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

[argentumandcoins 70]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Especially for A UNC/UNC coins to fit into. If the rest are mid/low grade they will have lost a fraction from the diameter. Peck is quite correct, the only really accurate test is a digtal caliper set which you can pick up for peanuts on ebay/tinternet.

[Gollum 2]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Especially for A UNC/UNC coins to fit into. If the rest are mid/low grade they will have lost a fraction from the diameter. Peck is quite correct, the only really accurate test is a digtal caliper set which you can pick up for peanuts on ebay/tinternet.

tinternet, is that an auction place special for tinted coinage ?

[Debbie 58]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Yes you are probably right. However I do have 7 of these folders and it doesn't seem to fit into any of the spaces.I take your point about it being a higher grade than some of my other coins Argumentus, but I have at least a dozen that I would have said were a similar grade and these seem to fit.I'll have a look to see if I can get hold of some digital calipers! Many thanks for your comments once again.

[Peckris 579]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Especially for A UNC/UNC coins to fit into. If the rest are mid/low grade they will have lost a fraction from the diameter. Peck is quite correct, the only really accurate test is a digtal caliper set which you can pick up for peanuts on ebay/tinternet.

tinternet, is that an auction place special for tinted coinage ?

There's a place up North. It's called Yorkshire. There they refer to t'internet. Clearly a ' has been missed.

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Yes you are probably right. However I do have 7 of these folders and it doesn't seem to fit into any of the spaces.I take your point about it being a higher grade than some of my other coins Argumentus, but I have at least a dozen that I would have said were a similar grade and these seem to fit.I'll have a look to see if I can get hold of some digital calipers! Many thanks for your comments once again.

Interesting that it won't fit into any space. Mind you it would only need to be the merest fraction oversize to result in a non-fit.

[argentumandcoins 70]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Especially for A UNC/UNC coins to fit into. If the rest are mid/low grade they will have lost a fraction from the diameter. Peck is quite correct, the only really accurate test is a digtal caliper set which you can pick up for peanuts on ebay/tinternet.

tinternet, is that an auction place special for tinted coinage ?

There's a place up North. It's called Yorkshire. There they refer to t'internet. Clearly a ' has been missed.

Sorry Peck, ' missed and also an i from "digital". Clearly my one fingered typing isn't up to scratch at night with a stomach full of Glenlivet (thanks a bunch for making me buy a couple of bottles for Christmas at £20 each Mr Tesco).

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Yes you are probably right. However I do have 7 of these folders and it doesn't seem to fit into any of the spaces.I take your point about it being a higher grade than some of my other coins Argumentus, but I have at least a dozen that I would have said were a similar grade and these seem to fit.I'll have a look to see if I can get hold of some digital calipers! Many thanks for your comments once again.

Interesting that it won't fit into any space. Mind you it would only need to be the merest fraction oversize to result in a non-fit.

[Peckris 579]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Especially for A UNC/UNC coins to fit into. If the rest are mid/low grade they will have lost a fraction from the diameter. Peck is quite correct, the only really accurate test is a digtal caliper set which you can pick up for peanuts on ebay/tinternet.

tinternet, is that an auction place special for tinted coinage ?

There's a place up North. It's called Yorkshire. There they refer to t'internet. Clearly a ' has been missed.

Sorry Peck, ' missed and also an i from "digital". Clearly my one fingered typing isn't up to scratch at night with a stomach full of Glenlivet (thanks a bunch for making me buy a couple of bottles for Christmas at £20 each Mr Tesco).

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Yes you are probably right. However I do have 7 of these folders and it doesn't seem to fit into any of the spaces.I take your point about it being a higher grade than some of my other coins Argumentus, but I have at least a dozen that I would have said were a similar grade and these seem to fit.I'll have a look to see if I can get hold of some digital calipers! Many thanks for your comments once again.

Interesting that it won't fit into any space. Mind you it would only need to be the merest fraction oversize to result in a non-fit.

Not even a BOGOFF??

[argentumandcoins 70]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Especially for A UNC/UNC coins to fit into. If the rest are mid/low grade they will have lost a fraction from the diameter. Peck is quite correct, the only really accurate test is a digtal caliper set which you can pick up for peanuts on ebay/tinternet.

tinternet, is that an auction place special for tinted coinage ?

There's a place up North. It's called Yorkshire. There they refer to t'internet. Clearly a ' has been missed.

Sorry Peck, ' missed and also an i from "digital". Clearly my one fingered typing isn't up to scratch at night with a stomach full of Glenlivet (thanks a bunch for making me buy a couple of bottles for Christmas at £20 each Mr Tesco).

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Yes you are probably right. However I do have 7 of these folders and it doesn't seem to fit into any of the spaces.I take your point about it being a higher grade than some of my other coins Argumentus, but I have at least a dozen that I would have said were a similar grade and these seem to fit.I'll have a look to see if I can get hold of some digital calipers! Many thanks for your comments once again.

Interesting that it won't fit into any space. Mind you it would only need to be the merest fraction oversize to result in a non-fit.

Not even a BOGOFF??

Nah! I can't grumble too much though as it's one of my favourites and it hasn't been this cheap in what seems a very long time

[Peckris 579]

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Especially for A UNC/UNC coins to fit into. If the rest are mid/low grade they will have lost a fraction from the diameter. Peck is quite correct, the only really accurate test is a digtal caliper set which you can pick up for peanuts on ebay/tinternet.

tinternet, is that an auction place special for tinted coinage ?

There's a place up North. It's called Yorkshire. There they refer to t'internet. Clearly a ' has been missed.

Sorry Peck, ' missed and also an i from "digital". Clearly my one fingered typing isn't up to scratch at night with a stomach full of Glenlivet (thanks a bunch for making me buy a couple of bottles for Christmas at £20 each Mr Tesco).

Sorry to make the obvious comment here - are you sure it isn't your Whitman folder? Some of those cardboard cutouts left something to be desired.

Yes you are probably right. However I do have 7 of these folders and it doesn't seem to fit into any of the spaces.I take your point about it being a higher grade than some of my other coins Argumentus, but I have at least a dozen that I would have said were a similar grade and these seem to fit.I'll have a look to see if I can get hold of some digital calipers! Many thanks for your comments once again.

Interesting that it won't fit into any space. Mind you it would only need to be the merest fraction oversize to result in a non-fit.

Not even a BOGOFF??

Nah! I can't grumble too much though as it's one of my favourites and it hasn't been this cheap in what seems a very long time

Compared to petrol, ANYTHING looks cheap!