Copper, 'toned' as only the US can?

[Accumulator 52]

What do you make of the toning on this coin? I just can't get over the feeling it's totally artificial, but otherwise a lovely penny.

[TomGoodheart 400]

What do you make of the toning on this coin? I just can't get over the feeling it's totally artificial, but otherwise a lovely penny.

Ridiculous. Now were it a proper colour .... but as it is? Just a novelty.

[1949threepence 3,367]

What do you make of the toning on this coin? I just can't get over the feeling it's totally artificial, but otherwise a lovely penny.

Looks artificially induced, and awful. Like it might have been dropped in a can of paraffin.

[pies 33]

Why,just why

[Accumulator 52]

What do you make of the toning on this coin? I just can't get over the feeling it's totally artificial, but otherwise a lovely penny.

Looks artificially induced, and awful. Like it might have been dropped in a can of paraffin.

Lit parafin too!

[VickySilver 830]

Possibly cleaned and retoned...??

[Peckris 579]

Me no like. The colours aren't AWFUL, just a tad unnatural. What I really dislike is the artificial reflectiveness off Vicky's hair.

[azda 979]

If you read his ebay text he says " Wörthy of a PREMIUM bid" so now you know why the americans dip them in petrol/Paraffin or whatever.

Wonder what the long term effects of this practise is plus sitting behind a slab.

[VickySilver 830]

A year or so ago I sent this seller a note of concern about his offerings, and he claimed that "he buys them toned that way" and knew not how they got that appearance - artificially toned (AT). Not quite sure how true that is....

[RLC35 288]

Vicky, I think the guy's ebay screenname gives him away..."GreatToning".....I don't usually like toned coins, but this one is attractive, but like Azda said...for how long!

[Gary 7]

give me an evenly toned milk chocolate colour any time!

I cannot imagine a coin toning naturally in that way.

[VickySilver 830]

You know, an interesting thought is that the very slabs themselves may develop markets for this type of toning and not for the expected reasons IMO: when you go a coin show in the USA, there are tables and tables (sometimes multiple hundreds of tables) and each is replete with stacks of slabs, all appearing uniform and very boring whether they contain an 100k USD bit or a 25 USD bit. So just perhaps, wild toning AT or not may break a bit of the monotony...

I absolutely am not excusing it, and am not in favour of it, just musing the point.

[numismatist 2]

Most of his coins are what he calls " Rainbow Toned "

His 1964 Kennedy Half Dollar is $2000.00 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

They normal sell for silver scrap price but he has thousands

of sales so the USA must be full of mugs !

[TomGoodheart 400]

Oh, I don't know. Perhaps I could be persuaded.

Not bad eh? Now, where did I throw those slabs?

[azda 979]

Where's me sunglasses

[TomGoodheart 400]

Where's me sunglasses

[numismatist 2]

I tried goggle "Fake rainbow toned coins" quite an eye opener

E-How even tells you how to cook your Morgan Dollars in the oven.

More seriously I now keep seeing incredible toned coins in the top

london auctions..See photos of these 1746 proofs. They fetched

world record prices . Are these " fake " tones ? ALL the 1746

Proofs I've seen in the past had dull tones.

[numismatist 2]

Last post showed the Shilling and Sixpence

Heres the HALFCROWN

[numismatist 2]

and heres the CROWN

[Accumulator 52]

Oh, I don't know. Perhaps I could be persuaded.

Not bad eh? Now, where did I throw those slabs?

That's outrageous!

I didn't think to look at his other items. Funny how they're nearly all 'toned' in the same way. He's wrecking some lovely coins in my opinion.

[numismatist 2]

Heres another...Seems to be some in just about EVERY sale now

[Coppers 58]

If any of you ever frequent US coin forums you'll very quickly see that a number of collectors are paying huge premiums often many multiples of market price for attractively toned coins and goodness help anyone who might suggest to them that these coins have had some help in getting that way.

[Paulus 1,975]

If any of you ever frequent US coin forums you'll very quickly see that a number of collectors are paying huge premiums often many multiples of market price for attractively toned coins and goodness help anyone who might suggest to them that these coins have had some help in getting that way.

I would be happy to suggest it!

How do we explain (for example) that, if they are all naturally toned, none of us have one like that in our collections? Or do we? I have a few beautifully toned coins but not like that!!

[Peckris 579]

If any of you ever frequent US coin forums you'll very quickly see that a number of collectors are paying huge premiums often many multiples of market price for attractively toned coins and goodness help anyone who might suggest to them that these coins have had some help in getting that way.

I would be happy to suggest it!

How do we explain (for example) that, if they are all naturally toned, none of us have one like that in our collections? Or do we? I have a few beautifully toned coins but not like that!!

Me neither. Red tones, gold, yellow, grey. But none are blue. Apart from a GF 1745/6 halfcrown but that's a bluish hue on a pewter grey background and I'm sure is genuine toning.

[azda 979]

Personally i Hope that those numpties that buy These artificially toned coins get their cumuppance and in 10 years or so their coins deteriorate in front if theur very eyes.

Are these peiple dumb enough (which they obviously are) to actually believe that their coins Tone naturally like that?

Our American Friends on this Forum are obviously excluded from my ramblings as you are aware that this cannot possibly happen to the millions of toned Coins that are being Sold in the US of A, but why theae huge premiums for a Bit of colour is beyond me. Gimme a felt tip pen and a Morgan Dollar and i'll make a nice Rainbow coloured coin to.....