Rummaging through my coin box

[jaggy 528]

I came across this penny from 1858.

Looks like an 8 over 3 but I am not a 'penny guy' and would appreciate the thoughts of those who are more expert than me.

[declanwmagee 122]

Here's the best place on the 'net to identify those...

Loupe in one hand, that page in the other.

[jaggy 528]

Here's the best place on the 'net to identify those...

Loupe in one hand, that page in the other.

Thanks for that. Think I have identified it:

Type 1, with W.W., larger date (11 beads) CP 1858 A.

[Rob 3,152]

I don't believe 1858 over 3 exists. The 'traditionally accepted' one with the flaw across the date I think is over a 7. I posted something to this effect in the last few months but can't remember in which thread.

[declanwmagee 122]

I don't believe 1858 over 3 exists. The 'traditionally accepted' one with the flaw across the date I think is over a 7. I posted something to this effect in the last few months but can't remember in which thread.

I remember the thread. Here's my example of the one Rob means...

[1949threepence 3,367]

Michael Gouby lists a very comprehensive review of the various 1858 penny types. They can be found here

He is of the same mind as Rob ~ that 1858/3 does not exist ("very unlikely")

[Rob 3,152]

Found it. Here

[Accumulator 52]

I remember the discussion too. I had this example, but the consensus was 8/8 rather than 8/3: